Hi everyone, I'd like to propose an experiment. Here's the story.
Stef is recording a podcast in his podcasting room.
The room has really good blinds, so that no light comes in from the outside,
and it's well sound proofed. The internet at his house was down all day.
Also, there's nobody home right now - we want to make sure that nobody can
come in the room for the next few minutes while we conduct the experiment.
We use a super power to freeze all the atoms in this room, including Stef itself
(Stef's made of atoms, so this should work, right?).
I'm talking a really good freeze, like we freeze all the atoms positions,
and their electrons, and even bosons, if we find any.
Somewhere nearby we rebuild Stef's room identically, and Stef itself, atom by atom.
We could use a super power for that or a reanimator, or we could borrow a teleport device
from a friend, and replace its move(atom) function with an illegal copy() function.
Anyway we do it, we get this second room with Stef in it, frozen with a funny face
like when we pause one of his youtube videos.
We now give the atoms in both rooms their momentums back (we can record those before the
freezing with a freezemometer) so that we can unpause the rooms, Stef included.
This is the crucial part of the experiment. What would happen next?
Would Stef's clone even be alive? Or would he (it?) fall on the floor
like a bunch of marbles? If life is a purely physical phenomenon, his atoms well into place
should have their relationships to one another preserved, still forming the molecules, cells,
tissues and finally the organism that we call Stef. When the electrons would start spinning again,
and jumping from atom to atom like they do, electrical impulses would continue their flow
through the brain, thought will continue to form, and if physics is right, Stef #2 would just
finish off his sentince, with the exact same motions as the real Stef.
In fact, if physics is right, the two Stefs would continue to podcast the exact same podcast.
The two physical systems called Stef would behave identically until the moment they try to leave the
room or open the blinds because that's when the environment around Stef changes. Science says that
physical systems tend to behave identically in identical environments and their behavior can only
diverge when their environments diverge.
So, what do you think it would happen?