A4E,
You did great, Thank you for taking the time to engage that person in conversation. I wonder if some conversations we have with people are fruitless but actually, we don't know how close they are to changing their mind.
Time for an anecdote:
My wife discovered that our 5 year old daughter had used markers on several of her dolls and her legos. Because of how my wife was raised, she was totally distressed on how to "address the problem" so she decided to not mention it to our daughter until my wife and I had a chance to discuss it.
I asked my wife, "How do you feel about what our daughter (Annabel) did?"
"Well, she ruined her dolls because I can't wash the marker off! I don't know what to do! Should we take her dolls away until she figures out how to take care of her stuff properly?"
I thought for a minute going over how that scenario might play out and dismissed that idea as a total lose-lose. I then asked, "does Annabel own her toys?"
"Yes, of course." my wife replied.
"What do you think the reason was as to Annabel's decision to 'explore her creativity' in this manner?" I said.
My wife then saw the look in my eye and smile on my face and exclaimed, "THAT'S IT! She just thought she was making her dolls more pretty! She was being creative!"
"Did we not give her the toys and told her that her toys belonged to her? Is our daughter free to do what she wants with her possessions? Do you think that Annabel will discover on her own that marking up her dolls is irreversible and that the changes she made she will have to accept?"
"Wow..." gasped my wife, "I was totally stressing on what to say to Annabel...
To make this story shorter, we waited till we saw that she was playing with one of her modified toys and asked if she liked the new colors she chose for her doll...
Our daughter then begin what was to be a 30 minute conversation of what colors she chose and why and what turned out good and what did not and it was really interesting her thought processes as to her creativity. She did ask if we could clean them and we said, "we can try together but I think it might be permanent."
We complemented her on her "new designs" and "choice of colors" and then said that she is free to do anything she wants to her toys but that some choices are regretfully long lasting.
The lesson that my wife and I took from this is that her actions were self-correcting and only required us to point some things out.
We never showed displeasure or anger towards what she did - only genuine curiosity and interest in her choices.
Weeks later, Annabel said our of the blue, "I don't think I'm going to put make-up on (color) my dolls anymore, I don't like the way it looks."