Jump to content

Ancap vs. Ancom youtube comments


Recommended Posts

BTW this video briefly shows Stef @ 1:13.

I wouldn't suggest watching this video, unless you are a glutton for punishment or sympathetic to communism. It's the typical leaders are bad; capitalism produces leaders; therefore capitalism is bad.

 

Anywho, about half way down the page an interesting exchange takes place. This cernunnos guy does a fantastic job of implementing the Socratic method to reveal the inconsistencies of the video/anarcho communism.

 

Look for

 
Just out of curiosity, how do "left" anarchists define capitalism?
 
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In a free society, you can't forcefully abolish anything.  Anarcho socialist is a contradiction right?

 

Correct. That is what youtube poster cernunnos makes a case for in his discussion with the video producer who tries, unsuccessfully to conflate the state with capitalism/property rights.

 

 

I wish they'd just say "communism". The video should be called "Arguments against communism".  

They view capitalism's abolition as defensive. 

I am confused. I thought the video was arguing against capitalism and proffering socialism. The arguments are quite muddled and not well thought out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I find the point made in the youtube comments about allowing each system to be tested (to see which one is most efficient/popular) helpful.

 

An analogy: Different games are played on the playground, often spontaneous and without conflicting with one another; when conflicts do arise, the parties involved want them resolved quickly (limited recess time) and amicably (don't want to ruin the spirit of fun for play).

 

Also from the youtube comments: I don't know all that a post-scarcity economy would entail, but maybe it's a shift in emphasis from some capital archetypes to others?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.